Do it!
When it comes to making decisions, there is no purpose in knowing what you should do if you don't actually do it. All the careful analysis, exploration of options, and evaluation of criteria means nothing if you fail to take action in the end.
Consequentiality and Reversibility
The key to knowing when to take action lies in understanding the nature of the decision at hand. Not all decisions are created equal - some have far-reaching, irreversible consequences, while others are easily undone.
The consequentiality of a decision refers to how much it affects the important things in your life - your relationships, your career, your finances, your health, and so on. Highly consequential decisions, like who to marry or where to live, can dramatically reshape the trajectory of your life. Less consequential decisions, like what to eat for lunch, have a more limited impact.
The reversibility of a decision refers to how easily its effects can be undone. Some decisions, like trying a new restaurant, are easily reversed if you don't like the outcome. Other decisions, like buying a house, are much harder to undo once made.
We can plot different types of decisions on a grid based on their consequentiality and reversibility:
The most critical decisions are those that are highly consequential and irreversible - the "lead dominoes" that can set off a chain reaction impacting the rest of your life. These are the decisions you want to be absolutely sure about before committing.
On the other end, decisions that are inconsequential and highly reversible are the ones you can often make quickly without much analysis paralysis. The cost of a mistake is low, so you can just "shoot a bullet" and learn from the results.
Principles for Action
With this framework in mind, here are three key principles to guide when and how you should take action on a decision:
The ASAP Principle
If the cost to undo the decision is low, make it as soon as possible.
For inconsequential, reversible decisions, don't overthink it. Choose quickly and move on. The longer you deliberate, the more likely you are to talk yourself out of taking action altogether.
The ALAP Principle
If the cost to undo a decision is high, make it as late as possible.
When the stakes are high and the consequences are difficult to reverse, you want to delay the final decision as long as possible. Keep gathering information, exploring options, and evaluating criteria until the very last moment before committing.
Remember, the cost of analysis itself is something to consider. Don't spend so much time deliberating that you miss your window of opportunity.
The Stop, Flop, Know Principle
Stop gathering more information and execute your decision when:
-
You've stopped gathering useful information. At a certain point, more data stops improving your accuracy and just feeds confirmation bias.
-
You start losing opportunities. When options begin to diminish, it's time to make a choice with the information you have.
-
You come to know something that makes the best path clear. Sometimes a critical insight emerges that makes the right decision obvious.
The key is to strike the right balance - don't rush into high-stakes decisions, but don't get paralyzed by analysis either. Know when you have enough to act, and be ready to do so before your options disappear.
Step 1
Evaluate the consequentiality and reversibility of the decision you're facing. Does it have high stakes and lasting impact, or is it more minor and easily undone?
Step 2
Apply the appropriate decision-making principle:
- For low-cost, reversible decisions, use the ASAP Principle and choose quickly.
- For high-stakes, irreversible decisions, use the ALAP Principle and delay committing until the last responsible moment.
- For any decision, use the Stop, Flop, Know Principle to know when to stop gathering information and take action.
Step 3
Implement fail-safes and precommitments to ensure you follow through on your decision, even when your defaults try to derail you. Things like trip wires, commander's intent, and tying your own hands can all help.
The ability to make tough calls and follow through on them is what separates those who achieve their goals from those who get stuck in perpetual indecision. By understanding the nature of the decision and applying the right principles, you can develop the judgment and discipline to convert your clear thinking into decisive action.